A Tribe Apart, Patrica Hersch
Directions: Please respond to the
following to prepare for discussion on the text each week. Responses should
be TYPED, double-spaced, 12-pt font, and 2-3 pages in length. Please back
up your responses with page numbers for reference for ALL responses. Your
responses will be collected in class each week. Please come prepared, no
late papers will be accepted.
Reading for Week 6 - Feb. 8
Preface, Prologue, Introduction,
Part I: Stepping Inside
-
First, state your understanding of Hersch's
rationale for this study. Then, ELABORATE on whether or not you agree with
her reasoning, and why/why not.
-
What is Hersch's question for this study?
-
Outline the steps of Hersch's methodology
for the study. Then, ELABORATE/critique how credible and/or dependable
is her methodology. (USE THE CRITERIA FOR QUALITATIVE RESEARCH TO ANSWER
THIS)
Some specifics to consider: How did she
gain access to her subjects? How did she narrow the study of her subjects?
Where did she begin? Where did she end up? What was the length of the study?
-
Hersch argues that "At the heart of the paradox
of adolescence is that much of what we worry about they take in stride
as normal" (p. 30), List some examples from the text of what is taken in
stride as normal versus what adults worry about.
-
What generalizations about the adolescent
world might we make based on the individual stories Hersch provides? Make
a list!