ARCHIVE - Tribe Apart Response Rubric

Tribe Apart Response Rubric

Preface, Prologue, Introduction, Part I: Stepping Inside

	Weak	OK	Good
Rationale for the study	Inaccurate, or superficial and incomplete, in identifying the rationale	Accurate identification of rationale, but lacking elaboration.	Accurate and elaborated identification of rationale.
Question of the Study	Does not accurately identify the main question in the study	Accurately identifies main question in the study	Accurately identifies main question in the study
Methodology	Does not adequately represent all steps in the methodology	Accurately represents most steps in the research methodology	Accurately represents all steps in the research methodology
Ability to critique methodology	Little to no elaboration of critique criteria, relies on personal opinion rather than research	Shows some ability to use research criteria for critique	Shows ability to use research criteria to critique, as well as elaborated, integrated thinking
Findings	Response shows little or some understanding of reading, may contain incomplete or inaccurate reporting of findings. Minimal engagement with the text/task	Response shows relatively close reading and accurate reporting of findings. Average engagement with the text/task	Response shows excellent close reading, accuracy of findings and thoughtful elaboration. Above average engagement with the text/task.