Emily
Exam Design, Paper #3
November 16, 2007
Final Exam Questions and Rubrics
1. (Citizen) How does the idea of the “form” stand in as a signifier for the body, and, based on what information is asked, how does this create a discourse of the body and citizen status?
Think about the concept ‘citizen’. We talked before in class after reading a passage from Tomorrow’s Eve that lead us to question the nature of the act of recording the body, and whether the act of recording altered the original. In relevance to the book, recording literally meant recording the voice of the body. However, can we apply our insight from this passage to the notion of the ‘form’? Does the form change the original body we are attempting to categorize? What does the form do to the concept of the citizen?
Emily
Exam Design, Paper #3
November 16, 2007
Final Exam Questions and Rubrics
1. (Citizen) How does the idea of the “form” stand in as a signifier for the body, and, based on what information is asked, how does this create a discourse of the body and citizen status?
Think about the concept ‘citizen’. We talked before in class after reading a passage from Tomorrow’s Eve that lead us to question the nature of the act of recording the body, and whether the act of recording altered the original. In relevance to the book, recording literally meant recording the voice of the body. However, can we apply our insight from this passage to the notion of the ‘form’? Does the form change the original body we are attempting to categorize? What does the form do to the concept of the citizen?
Think back to our revue workshop from week four when we “cited” texts by cutting them up and making them work for our purposes. Remember that this performative exercise was to understand citation as a discourse, that the cited might actually become the product.
In terms of semiotics, does the signifier become the signified, and/ or does the signified become the signifier? Remember, linguistics and semiotics are not just words – they also include any system of meaning and communication.
2. (Self) Can the use of technology create a full and complete combination of the organic human with the cyborg, and when will the lines become indefinable? And why does this coupling or hybridism often carry a stigma?
For this question, the student could consider Das Shone Machden (The Beautiful Girl) by Hannah Hoch. Using a photomontage as an allegory for modernization, how does Hoch use the chaotic placement of synthetic and organic elements to express the rapid expanse of technology in the social realm? Do you see a transformation of personhood, from body into machine? As Jennifer Gonzalez writes in the article, “Envisioning Cyborg Bodies”:
“This term [Miscegenated] not only trails a violent political history in the United States but is also dependent on a eugenicist, genocidal concept of illegitimate matings. At the same time, this may be the very reason that certain writers have employed the term – to point out the “forbidden” nature of the “coupling” of human and machine.”
Is this “coupling” seen as a threat to our humanity, our personhood? What does this terminology being used say about the discourse about embodiment? Does the cyborg always refer to the product of sexual procreation, or can characteristics of one become the other (as in, cyborg with human attributes, or humans with synthetic additions)?
3. (Subject) How is space and setting used as a symbol of power and hierarchy to create the subjected body in “The Metropolis”? How do bodies within these settings form and act within models of discipline and power?
Think about the way the buildings are constructed and set up, where they are in the different layers of the city, and how workplaces vary. Draw on the passage from Michel Foucault in “The Political Investment of the Body” In The Body: A Reader by Mariam Fraser and Monica Greco:
“This political investment of the body is bound up, in accordance with complex reciprocal relations, with its economic use; it is largely as a force of production that the body is invested with relations of power and domination; but, on the other hand, its constitution as labor power is possible only if it is caught up in a system of subjection; The body is a useful force only if it is both a productive body and a subjected body.”
In terms of the subjected/ productive body and the Foucaultian concept of objectivity, explain how the notion of the political investment of the body relates to the use of setting and space as a control of bodies in “Metropolis.’ Also, consider a quotation regarding the environment of bodies in “Space, Time, and Perversion” by Elizabeth Grosz, in which she states:
“As a political and hence a social relation, the body politic, whatever form it may take, justifies and naturalizes itself with reference to some form of hierarchical organization modeled on the (presumed and projected) structure of the body.” In what ways does the construct of the city in “Metropolis” function to express Lang’s vision of the subjected body, and how does Grosz’s comment relate?
Possible Exam questions answered! (kind of) quick notes. . .stream of thought
What are some things I think about as I look over these questions?
- By claiming identity, your identity is claiming you
The form (example forms given in class. . .we got the census form) what were the questions asked in 1970? Marital status, # children, occupation . . .talk about claiming what claims you!
Scott Turner Schofield. . .asked him what the point of creating more “updated” vocabulary does to the idea, and if it’s necessary. He agreed, and referenced the fact that terminology does in fact make us what we are or what we consider ourselves to be.
Visibility of the social discourses within the work? Scott brought to light social aspects revolving around transgender issues . . .how people reacted to him, what he was feeling based on what happened around him. . . .Pauline Pantsdown made fun of and highlighted Pauline Hanson’s political policy of nationalism, and in turn relied heavily on blatant and offensive humor.
]]>Possible Exam questions answered! (kind of) quick notes. . .stream of thought
What are some things I think about as I look over these questions?
- By claiming identity, your identity is claiming you
The form (example forms given in class. . .we got the census form) what were the questions asked in 1970? Marital status, # children, occupation . . .talk about claiming what claims you!
Scott Turner Schofield. . .asked him what the point of creating more “updated” vocabulary does to the idea, and if it’s necessary. He agreed, and referenced the fact that terminology does in fact make us what we are or what we consider ourselves to be.
Visibility of the social discourses within the work? Scott brought to light social aspects revolving around transgender issues . . .how people reacted to him, what he was feeling based on what happened around him. . . .Pauline Pantsdown made fun of and highlighted Pauline Hanson’s political policy of nationalism, and in turn relied heavily on blatant and offensive humor.
- Disciplinary effects of power on the body. Beau Travail and Metropolis:
“The body becomes a useful force only if it is both a productive body and a subjected body.”
Within Beau Travail: as the disembodied spirit. The more rigorous and disciplined the body is, the closer it comes to transcendentalism. Work involves monotonous, menial yet necessary tasks. Mental processes, labor almost more a question of honor than just straight profit, more of a grey area between owner/ruler and worker/ subjected body.
Within Metropolis: as a subterranean worker ant. More machinist, more cyborg-ish. Very subjected body without the good of the workers involved. Interesting that workers world is below ground, a direct parallel to workers ants?
One main difference is the relationship between workers and owners. Galoup maintains a more personal relationship with his troop, if not simply because of the number he is controlling, whereas the inventors and owners are so far removed from the labor in Metropolis. The labor in metropolis is for direct production and profit; where as the labor in Beau Travail is more for the sake of the whole small group.
- The prostheses - a device, either external or implanted, that substitutes for or supplements a missing or defective part of the body.
Substitution and supplements are key terms in this case, especially for roles played in theatre.
Good Person of Schezwan – obvious prostheses in the case of how the character Shiu-Ta supplements Shen-The. The bodily function of Shui-Ta? To masculinize Shen-Ten, create a bigger space for her feelings and needs. Limitations? Biological – when shen-teh becomes pregnant, the prostheses of Shui-Ta is no longer legitimate or believable.
In the Balcony, the examples are so very numerous because the characters are often fluid and changing, and many times just unclear as to who is what.
– Tomorrow’s Eve Theatre/ Movie production . . . what would we use to implement Brechtian techniques?
Music in minor key, kinda unnerving music, not easy to hum along to, not a catchy ballad
Perhaps Hadaly could speak with a human voice, possibly a male’s voice with a “woman’s” cyborg body.
Style of film would have to be black and white, especially since we’re so used to color TV/Movies, that it allows us to be swept away more easily into the plot . . .black and white might alienate us?
Unnatural stage lighting/ scene lighting
What’s so great about alienation – reminds the viewer the production is exactly that – a representation of reality, not the reality itself. His satire on technology is so that people reflect on the current state of society at the time . . .but the message almost seems to transcend time in that its message is still applicable now.
5) – what sticks out to me in this picture:
-fake mustache
- earring
- tear tattoo
- shaved head
- Why are these things possible more important than the fact they he an Asian male? Construction of identity. . .I think it is way more interesting that the signifiers are made to look really obvious and phony. But even still, his face would look completely different without these add-ons. The “citation” or the mention and suggestion of another identity is apparent in this picture, one that is easily achieved and removable (save the tattoo).
6) - Cyborg: a person whose physiological functioning is aided by or dependent upon a mechanical or electronic device; a fictional or hypothetical person whose physical abilities are extended beyond normal human limitations by mechanical elements built into the body.
a)
b) the telephone – at this point has completely changed the way we handle our bodies. Even when it was first invented, people did not utilize it to the degree in which we do now. We use it as a locator (When we’re lost, or when we want to find out where someone is), as a social pastime, as an extension of what we can access. Pizza delivery?
]]>
Here's what I'm thinking in my philosophical banter head space : Music that involves electricity is a cyborg, and is not organic music. This is a really blatant, unresearched statement, and not that I actually am applying this to my life, but please, refute me on this, for humor's sake.
Here's what I'm thinking in my philosophical banter head space : Music that involves electricity is a cyborg, and is not organic music. This is a really blatant, unresearched statement, and not that I actually am applying this to my life, but please, refute me on this, for humor's sake.
I really enjoyed Martha Rosler's 'The East is Red, the West is Bending" was especially clever - the (purposefully) awkward attempt at teaching people how to make Asian food using an Americanized "non-primitive" method, the electric wok! I liked the subtle satire, especially when it's aimed at American economics and consumption...she was so confident in her cooking abilities in her sunglasses..yet was reading from an instruction manual! It was such a generic representation...I'm just not sure how that is necessarily feminist...is it just because she was a woman poineer in the film industry at the time?
]]>
I really enjoyed Martha Rosler's 'The East is Red, the West is Bending" was especially clever - the (purposefully) awkward attempt at teaching people how to make Asian food using an Americanized "non-primitive" method, the electric wok! I liked the subtle satire, especially when it's aimed at American economics and consumption...she was so confident in her cooking abilities in her sunglasses..yet was reading from an instruction manual! It was such a generic representation...I'm just not sure how that is necessarily feminist...is it just because she was a woman poineer in the film industry at the time?
]]>Oh Database, oh Database,
How I long to hold your face
Please whisper sweet categorical nothings in my ear,
and tell me all the decimal placements that I want to hear.
It began that cold, bland winter back in 2001
When I clicked your mouse, accessed you, then
There was no greater fun
Than assisting inquiring patrons, students, teachers in their quests.
My capabilities extended, enhanced!
You are the very best.
From that day on I swore and swore
That I would be so faithful as to use your insight, wisdom
From then on, forevermore!
]]>Oh Database, oh Database,
How I long to hold your face
Please whisper sweet categorical nothings in my ear,
and tell me all the decimal placements that I want to hear.
It began that cold, bland winter back in 2001
When I clicked your mouse, accessed you, then
There was no greater fun
Than assisting inquiring patrons, students, teachers in their quests.
My capabilities extended, enhanced!
You are the very best.
From that day on I swore and swore
That I would be so faithful as to use your insight, wisdom
From then on, forevermore!
]]>Beau Travail: A Political Investment of a Body
A writer, whether they choose to write books, screenplays, operas, etc., selects their medium with a specific intent – to convey a certain aesthetic relevant to the philosophical or artistic principals of the story or idea they are trying to tell. In this same way, Claire Denis chose to create Beau Travail as a ninety-minute film that relies heavily on imagery and sound as an integral part of the concept of the film. The concept of the film, which illustrates the maintenance and building of soldier bodies in the French Army in post-colonial Africa, is comparable to Michel Foucault’s article “The Political Investment of the Body” in The Body; A Reader by Mariam Fraser and Monica Greco, in that it studies ways in which bodies act within models of discipline and power.
]]>Beau Travail: A Political Investment of a Body
A writer, whether they choose to write books, screenplays, operas, etc., selects their medium with a specific intent – to convey a certain aesthetic relevant to the philosophical or artistic principals of the story or idea they are trying to tell. In this same way, Claire Denis chose to create Beau Travail as a ninety-minute film that relies heavily on imagery and sound as an integral part of the concept of the film. The concept of the film, which illustrates the maintenance and building of soldier bodies in the French Army in post-colonial Africa, is comparable to Michel Foucault’s article “The Political Investment of the Body” in The Body; A Reader by Mariam Fraser and Monica Greco, in that it studies ways in which bodies act within models of discipline and power.
Film circulates differently through audiences than, say, academic journal articles, novels, musicals, or newspapers, and also appeals to a different type of audience. It creates an accessible, entertaining aesthetic that is very easily available to the masses through pop-culture, especially with evolving markets that allow for new Internet businesses such as Net-flix or You-Tube. This is not to say that books are no longer in the running when it comes to media sales, but it seems that oftentimes, the masses would prefer to see a story rather than read it. Perhaps it is because a film creates the image and sound of a setting for the viewer, rather than requiring the reader to use their imagination to conjure up images, vocal styling or backgrounds. Perhaps it is simply because movies and films can be a collective and social experience, or one that stimulates multiple senses at once, rather than just cognitive thought. In any case, film is often seen more in pop-culture, as music is, and maybe that is because of the utilization of certain tools of expression.
With these tools of imagery and sound, Denis creates a very effective setting that is almost more communicative than the plot itself, which is, on the surface, quite simple. By absorbing the film with only the direct storyline in mind, the viewer would interpret the plot as the reminiscence of a French army officer who was demoted after punishing a defiant legionnaire by leaving him for dead in a barren desert after an explosion of pent up aggression and jealousy. However, if the viewer pays close attention to the use of imagery, camera angels, soundtrack, and background noise, there is a much more complex underlying expression of masculinity and power, and how the body is subjected to power.
For instance, in the beginning of the movie there is a scene showing the soldiers training and staying physically fit by jumping in and out of giant pits, crawling under ropes, running, and jumping over walls. There is no background music, only the sound of boots stomping the dirt below them, scraping the walls with their skin and clothes, and soft grunting noises from exertion. The camera follows closely, changing shots very rapidly, and showing close-ups of segments of their bodies, rather than the whole person. It creates a sense of urgency and hazardous circumstances, which is exactly what the legionnaires were conditioning and disciplining their bodies for.
In a later scene, it shows the soldiers performing a much more domestic, tedious task – ironing. They stood still, each behind their own ironing board, the camera frame showing all three bodies at once and only changing to show a close-up of the iron steaming. Galoup, the commanding officer, steps through to oversee their progress, and comment that ironing is a step to “elegance in and under uniforms,” almost alluding to the Zen-like qualities of the miniscule soldier tasks as a means to perfection and simplicity. The noise was minimal if not almost non-existent. A previously “feminine” task, the tedious act of ironing was transformed into an incredibly masculine one: it now conditioned the body to find discipline and self-control, and also respect and awareness in rank without self-importance.
This scene reminded me immediately of a section in the beginning of Michel Foucault’s “The Political Investment of the Body” :
“The body becomes a useful force only if it is both a productive body and a subjected body. This subjection . . .can also be direct, physical, pitting force against force, bearing on material elements . . . it may be calculated, organized, technically thought out; it may be subtle, make use neither of weapons nor of terror and yet remain of a physical order (p100).”
The act of ironing is productive to a point, but it is also a subtle symbol of the power that not only Galoup exerts on his subjected legionnaires, but also that which the legionnaires exert on themselves in complying with rules and regulations. It is an unsaid representation of their rank and docility, as well as self-control. In this way, the force of Galoup is against the force of the soldiers - which seems to reiterate Galoup’s power- but in a non-violent, practical way. In the same way, Galoup is only a useful force if he is also a productive body (by controlling and organizing the soldiers with his power) and a subjected body (by acting as a node in the military hierarchy, and also by only having power when his soldiers follow his commands).
In another scene, the soldiers are doing their daily stretches in a large, uniform group. They move simultaneously, almost as one body, and their eyes are closed which makes them seem unaware of their surroundings or their individuality, just the importance of their movements as a group and their loyalty to each other. Foucault writes that there is a knowledge of the body, which involves the ability to control the forces of the body, and that this understanding makes what can be thought of as the “political technology of the body” (p100). This phrase to me, relates to the soldiers use of their bodies, or the governing and control of the expertise of their bodies during these harmonized stretches. By moving together as a collective whole, the soldiers are not just physically training their body by learning muscle control and balance, but also the control of gracefulness and moving together for the sake of the whole. The camera pans around the group in a circle, engulfing them and creating an all inclusive, communal effect with a loud and gripping background song that consists of many males singing in unison a haunting voluminous melody.
In a similar way, Galoup and Sentain, the perfect legionnaire and Galoup’s rival, are shown in a dance-like ritual in a later scene, circling each other, in step with and slowly closing in on each other, with confrontational eye contact. The camera either shows an open shot from far away, showing how they move about each other and the distance between them, or extreme close-ups of their faces, highlighting mainly their intense eyes or mouths. Galoup looks enraged with disdain and jealousy, most likely by Sentain’s defiant smirk and absolutely ideal masculine, disciplined body. The music is more tribal this time, more war-like, rhythmic, and provoking. All these factors combine to create that same sense of urgency as in the training scene, except that, in this scene, there are two direct opponents utilizing all they’ve learned from their training, rather than preparations for future confrontations.
In terms of how modern technology gives this film certain qualities that are unattainable in something like literature or early modern theater, I think of how lighting is used in one specific scene to capture an aspect of the story. After a long day of rigorous training and discipline rituals, the soldiers build a bonfire for entertainment where they proceed to dance around it, play drums in tribal rhythms, and essentially let out aggressions or natural tendencies - this is a portion of their day where they aren’t necessarily required to follow strict codes of conduct. The low lighting from the fire generates a very mysterious feeling, one of dimness and shadows that could potentially be representative of the soldiers’ want for individuality and aversion to constructs at that moment. Because they are immersed in light throughout the day, they are exposed to each other as other soldiers, followers of rules and members of a whole. But because of the use of modern technology with film, we can see how the darkness plays with their characters and changes their representations. In the end, and this is most likely due to the dark atmosphere and release of pent up aggression allowed that night, two of the soldiers begin to fight each other due to a miniscule and sarcastic exchange of words from earlier that day – their individuality was asserted and they were, at least for a moment, breaking conduct rules and codes of honor. This scene was much more effective and climactic with the help of lighting and sound to show this released aggression, and may not have been so obvious or well explained through another medium.
Film is an effective way to combine sound and image, as are musicals and plays or any live performance art. However, camera angles, close-ups, or open shots are something that live performance is somewhat lacking. Film also can portray emotions and situations by using certain actions the body makes, rather than having them explained in a literal sense, as some types literature do. The use of the visual aid and sound in the movie Beau Travail is so poignant, so integral to the plot and setting, that it almost seems impossible to express through another medium. For instance, the use of the enormously expansive and barren desert for a background could not be easily modeled in a live performance theater, just as the haunting musical score could not be used in a novel or academic journal article. The methods and elements used for expression are key to developing all aspects of a story, idea, or concept, and Beau Travail does a thorough job of this through its specifically chosen medium.
Works Cited
Foucault, Michel. “The Political Investment of the Body.” The Body: A Reader. Ed. Mariam Fraser and Monica Greco. London and New York: Routledge, 2005. 100-104.
]]>
Late in the year 2007, month and exact date unknown, the VCR, resident of the Beanblossom/Aper residence, was reportedly found dead resting upon the Magnavox Television in the living room. The VCR lived to be 21 years old after its initial manufacturing year of 1986, and was apparently in good health and working condition until an incident with a fauly VHS tape titled "Waterworld, starring Kevin Costner, left it with a broken hinge door, a few lights out, buttons removed by force, and a slower pace of reeling film. The VHS, starring Kevin Costner, was removed and cited for improper reel usage, and was issued a ticket.
The VCR was a graduate of Sony Entertainment, 1986, and did not pursue a higher degree after entering the work force. It is survived by its Magnavox TV, Sony Playstation, an extensive collection VHS collection, used playstation games, and generic reception antenna. After its death it was replaced with its socially valued updated hybrid offspring, the VHS/DVD combination player.
Ceremonies will be held at 9:30 am Sat, Aug. 21,2007 at Saint 901 East Winona Apartments, back alley dumpster site, adjacent to the laundry room, Chicago, IL 60637.
]]>
Late in the year 2007, month and exact date unknown, the VCR, resident of the Beanblossom/Aper residence, was reportedly found dead resting upon the Magnavox Television in the living room. The VCR lived to be 21 years old after its initial manufacturing year of 1986, and was apparently in good health and working condition until an incident with a fauly VHS tape titled "Waterworld, starring Kevin Costner, left it with a broken hinge door, a few lights out, buttons removed by force, and a slower pace of reeling film. The VHS, starring Kevin Costner, was removed and cited for improper reel usage, and was issued a ticket.
The VCR was a graduate of Sony Entertainment, 1986, and did not pursue a higher degree after entering the work force. It is survived by its Magnavox TV, Sony Playstation, an extensive collection VHS collection, used playstation games, and generic reception antenna. After its death it was replaced with its socially valued updated hybrid offspring, the VHS/DVD combination player.
Ceremonies will be held at 9:30 am Sat, Aug. 21,2007 at Saint 901 East Winona Apartments, back alley dumpster site, adjacent to the laundry room, Chicago, IL 60637.
]]>
Here is what I am interested in:
- public access to humans, personal information in institutions and internet
- how senses of privacy has changed over time
- how access to info on body has changed
- technology and information science's contribution
- control of information distribution,why this has changed, and social implications of th changes
OR
- children's literature
- children's animation
- sexuality in children's literature
- maybe consisting of writing a children's novel/ book
- maybe trying to do children's animation?
Here's how I would like to do it:
- with implementation of creative endeavors
- research intensive, critical and responsive
- in a fairly organized manner, but not so very professional that we can't be 5 min late here and there.
- being very passionate about the subject matter. . .not just wanted to skim the top, but really dive into issues and questions
- opposing viewpoints very invited
Leave comments if your interested in collaborating! Thanks.
]]>
Here is what I am interested in:
- public access to humans, personal information in institutions and internet
- how senses of privacy has changed over time
- how access to info on body has changed
- technology and information science's contribution
- control of information distribution,why this has changed, and social implications of th changes
OR
- children's literature
- children's animation
- sexuality in children's literature
- maybe consisting of writing a children's novel/ book
- maybe trying to do children's animation?
Here's how I would like to do it:
- with implementation of creative endeavors
- research intensive, critical and responsive
- in a fairly organized manner, but not so very professional that we can't be 5 min late here and there.
- being very passionate about the subject matter. . .not just wanted to skim the top, but really dive into issues and questions
- opposing viewpoints very invited
Leave comments if your interested in collaborating! Thanks.
]]>