Logical Foundations of Science and Computing, Fall 2007
Chapter 1-12 Summary of A. Einstein's Special Relativity Paper
What follows is a brief summary of what I perceive are the key ideas of
the first 14 chapters of A. Einstein's paper
The Special Theory of Relativity
found in the book Relativity: The Special and General Theory by Albert
Einstein (translated by Robert W. Lawson).
The paper is organized with the following architecture.
- Chapters 1-4 establish the background definitions and assumptions.
- Chapters 5-7 set up the conflict in classical mechanics involving the
constancy of the speed of light.
- Chapters 8-10 introduce a new conception of space and time that sidesteps
the conflict.
- Chapters 11-17 elaborate the new relativistic mechanics and some of its
implications.
Chapter 1 - Physical Meaning of Geometric Propositions
Dr. Einstein shows us how to relate a mathematical model of space with
"real" space as we perceive it. The mathematical model he discusses is a
geometric model derived from Euclid's ancient Greek work on geometry.
Chapter 2 - The System of Co-ordinates
This chapter shows how to locate objects in space and measure distances between
objects in a Euclidean model of space using a Cartesian coordinate system.
Every object in space can be identified by three coordinates. All coordinate
systems must be attached to a body of reference.
Chapter 3 - Space and Time in Classical Mechanics
In order to deal with objects in motion one needs to add time to a model of
space. Chapter 3 introduces the model of space and time used by classical
mechanics and describes what motion looks like. Dr. Einstein shows that
bodies in motion do not have an independently existing trajectory, rather,
only a trajectory relative to a body of reference. He implicitly suggests
that we must think of every object in space and time as identified by 4
coordinates. The last coordinate is the moment in time of observing an
object in space.
Chapter 4 - The Galilean System of Co-ordinates
Dr. Einstein introduces a requirement on any reference body and system
of coordinates. In order to be a permissible reference body and system
of coordinates all objects being observed must obey the law of inertia:
A body removed sufficiently far from other bodies continues in a state
of rest or of uniform motion in a straight line
Such a permissible body of reference and coordinate system is referred to as
a Galilean system of coordinates. (Sometimes I refer to a Galilean system
of coordinates as a frame of reference.)
Chapter 5 - The Principle of Relativity (in the Restricted Sense)
This somewhat challenging chapter discusses what it means to observe
the same phenomena from different frames of reference that are in uniform
motion relative to each other. Dr. Einstein informs us that the principle
of relativity is the widely held belief that the laws of mechanics remain
equivalent independent of your frame of reference. Paraphrasing Dr.
Einstein's words in paragraph 3 of Chapter 5: for two frames of reference
K and K' in uniform motion relative to each other,
natural phenomena run their course according to the same general laws.
The restricted sense has to do with reference frames in uniform motion
as opposed to more involved forms of relative motion that exhibit acceleration.
Chapter 6 - The Theorem of the Addition of Velocities in Classical Mechanics
Chapter 6 summarizes the common-sense understanding of the addition of
velocities of moving objects assumed by classical mechanics. This is a direct
setup for the conflict described in the next chapter.
Chapter 7 - The Apparent Incompatibility of the Law of Propagation of Light
with the Principle of Relativity
Here the essential conflict of classical mechanics and the observed constancy of
the speed of light is established. The conflict as described by Dr. Einstein
reflects the foundational quandary physics was in at the turn of the century.
According to the theorem of the addition of velocities in classical mechanics,
the speed of light should be different in different frames of reference moving
uniformly relative to each other. Yet the constancy of the speed of light was
a law of physics that should remain the same in all frames of reference,
according to the principle of relativity. Dr. Einstein claims that the
special theory of relativity side-steps this conflict. How? Read on.
Chapter 8 - On the Idea of Time in Physics
Chapter 8 begins the process of re-conceptualizing time and space in order
to achieve the new relativistic mechanics. What fundamental assumption
was the physics community unwittingly clinging to at the time? Dr. Einstein
will boldly propose that our concept of absolute time and space must go. But
first he must carefully define time according to the method by which it is
measured. All defintions in physics are operational definitions,
meaning that all fundamental properties upon which physics is based are defined
according to the method by which they are measured.
Chapter 9 - The Relativity of Simultaneity
Chapter 9 sets out to demonstrate that the concept or idea of Simultaneous
Events can only be meaningful when expressed relative to a body
of reference. The chapter presents a thought experiment that
examines two lightening strikes as seen from an embankment or from a train
moving with respect to the embankment. Einstein shows that if the two lightening
strikes are perceived as simultaneous from one of the reference points then
they will not be simultaneous from the other. A very important point of this
chapter is that Dr. Einstein's conclusion that time itself cannot be perceived
as the same from the two different reference points - there can be no
absolute significance to any statement of time.
Chapter 10 - On the Relativity of the Concept of Distance.
Not only are time measurements relative to a reference body, but distance
measurements are relative to a reference body as well. There can be no
absolute significance to any statement of distance.
In general Dr. Einstein is suggesting that
we must be prepared to accept that time and distance are strictly local
phenomena
that change depending on motion. We must accept that time and length
change for objects in motion relative to the observer. Identically
constructed clocks can run at different rates. Biological aging (a kind of
clock) can run at different rates.
Chapter 11 - The Lorentz Transformation
The Lorentz Transformation gives the method of translating the 4 dimensional
spacetime coordinates of an event relative to one reference body into different
4 dimensional spacetime coordinates relative to another reference body.
The transformation must be such that the laws of physics are the same in
both reference frames -- even if the actual space and time coordinates
are different.
Chapter 12 - The Behaviour of Measuring-rods and Clocks in Motion
This chapter derives the time dilation factor and the distance
contraction factor for measurements on bodies in motion relative to an
observer at rest.