S-0788.2
_______________________________________________
SENATE BILL 5478
_______________________________________________
State of Washington
56th Legislature
1999 Regular Session
By Senators Fraser, Spanel and Winsley
Read first time 01/25/1999. Referred to Committee on Environmental
Quality & Water Resources.
AN ACT Relating to water flows; amending
RCW 90.54.020, 90.22.010,
90.22.030, 90.03.345, 90.03.247, 75.20.050, 90.03.380, 90.42.080,
90.14.160, 90.14.170, and 90.14.180; adding new sections to chapter
90.03 RCW; creating a new section; and repealing RCW 90.22.060.
BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON:
{+ NEW SECTION. +} Sec. 1.
The legislature finds that adequate
streamflows and lake levels are necessary for protecting and recovering
salmon stocks and for achieving the state's high standards for
protecting perennial water systems declared in the 1971 water resource
fundamentals. To achieve adequate flows requires as a predicate
that
flow levels be expeditiously adopted and be based upon the best
available science. The establishment of these levels should
occur as
early as possible in streams and rivers in which salmon populations
are
in danger of extinction. Once levels are established, measures
should
be implemented to ensure that existing flows are not diminished
below
these levels, and that further measures are taken to restore
streamflows currently experiencing seasonal or periodic levels
below
these established levels. It is therefore the purpose of
this act to
provide additional authority in the state's water code to undertake
these measures and to provide guidance to administering agencies
in
establishing priorities to address critical needs such as restoration
of depressed salmon stocks.
Sec. 2. RCW 90.54.020 and 1997 c
442 s 201 are each amended to
read as follows:
Utilization and management of the waters
of the state shall be
guided by the following general declaration of fundamentals:
(1) Uses of water for domestic, stock
watering, industrial,
commercial, agricultural, irrigation, hydroelectric power production,
mining, fish and wildlife maintenance and enhancement, recreational,
and thermal power production purposes, and preservation of
environmental and aesthetic values, and all other uses compatible
with
the enjoyment of the public waters of the state, are declared to
bebeneficial.
(2) Allocation of waters among potential
uses and users shall be
based generally on the securing of the maximum net benefits for
the
people of the state. Maximum net benefits shall constitute
total
benefits less costs including opportunities lost.
(3) The quality of the natural environment
shall be protected and,
where possible, enhanced as follows:
(a) Perennial rivers and streams of the
state shall be retained
with (({- base -})) flows (({- necessary to provide for preservation
of
-})) {+ adequate to support +} wildlife, fish, scenic, aesthetic
and
other environmental values, and navigational values. Lakes
and ponds
shall be retained substantially in their natural condition.
Withdrawals of water which would conflict therewith shall be authorized
only in those situations where it is clear that overriding
considerations of the public interest will be served.
(b) Waters of the state shall be of high
quality. Regardless of
the quality of the waters of the state, all wastes and other materials
and substances proposed for entry into said waters shall be provided
with all known, available, and reasonable methods of treatment
prior to
entry. Notwithstanding that standards of quality established
for the
waters of the state would not be violated, wastes and other materials
and substances shall not be allowed to enter such waters which
will
reduce the existing quality thereof, except in those situations
where
it is clear that overriding considerations of the public interest
will
be served. Technology-based effluent limitations or standards
for
discharges for municipal water treatment plants located on the
Chehalis, Columbia, Cowlitz, Lewis, or Skagit river shall be adjusted
to reflect credit for substances removed from the plant intake
waterif:
(i) The municipality demonstrates that
the intake water is drawn
from the same body of water into which the discharge is made; and
(ii) The municipality demonstrates that
no violation of receiving
water quality standards or appreciable environmental degradation
willresult.
{+ (c) Protection and restoration of streamflows
adequate to
support sustainable populations of salmon and trout stocks
shall be a
high priority in the planning and management of the state's waterresources.
+}
(4) The development of multipurpose water
storage facilities shall
be a high priority for programs of water allocation, planning,
management, and efficiency. The department, other state agencies,
local governments, and planning units formed under section 107
or 108
of this act shall evaluate the potential for the development of
new
storage projects and the benefits and effects of storage in reducing
damage to stream banks and property, increasing the use of land,
providing water for municipal, industrial, agricultural, power
generation, and other beneficial uses, and improving streamflow
regimes
for fisheries and other instream uses.
(5) Adequate and safe supplies of water
shall be preserved and
protected in potable condition to satisfy human domestic needs.
(6) Multiple-purpose impoundment structures
are to be preferred
over single-purpose structures. Due regard shall be given
to means and
methods for protection of fishery resources in the planning for
and
construction of water impoundment structures and other artificialobstructions.
(7) Federal, state, and local governments,
individuals,
corporations, groups and other entities shall be encouraged to
carry
out practices of conservation as they relate to the use of the
waters
of the state. In addition to traditional development approaches,
improved water use efficiency and conservation shall be emphasized
in
the management of the state's water resources and in some cases
will be
a potential new source of water with which to meet future needs
throughout the state.
(8) Development of water supply systems,
whether publicly or
privately owned, which provide water to the public generally in
regional areas within the state shall be encouraged. Development
of
water supply systems for multiple domestic use which will not serve
the
public generally shall be discouraged where water supplies are
available from water systems serving the public.
(9) Full recognition shall be given in
the administration of water
allocation and use programs to the natural interrelationships of
surface and ground waters.
(10) Expressions of the public interest
will be sought at all
stages of water planning and allocation discussions.
(11) Water management programs, including
but not limited to, water
quality, flood control, drainage, erosion control and storm runoff
are
deemed to be in the public interest.
Sec. 3. RCW 90.22.010 and 1997 c
32 s 4 are each amended to read
as follows: {+ (1) +} The department of
ecology (({- may -})) {+ shall +}
establish (({- minimum -})) water flows or levels for streams,
lakes or
other public waters (({- for the purposes of protecting -})) {+
adequate to support +} fish, game, birds or other wildlife resources,
or recreational or aesthetic values of said public waters whenever
it
appears to be in the public interest to establish the same.
In
addition, the department of ecology shall, when requested by the
department of fish and wildlife to protect fish, game or other
wildlife
resources under the jurisdiction of the requesting state agency,
or if
the department of ecology finds it necessary to preserve water
quality,
establish such (({- minimum -})) flows or levels as are (({- required
-
})) {+ adequate +} to protect the resource or preserve the water
quality described in the request or determination. Any request
submitted by the department of fish and wildlife shall include
a
statement setting forth the need for establishing a (({- minimum
-}))
flow or level. When the department acts to preserve water
quality, it
shall include a similar statement with the proposed rule filed
with the
code reviser. This section shall not apply to waters artificially
stored in reservoirs, provided that in the granting of storage
permits
by the department of ecology in the future, full recognition shall
be
given to downstream (({- minimum -})) flows, if any there may be,
which
have theretofore been established hereunder.
{+ (2) The department of ecology shall
incorporate the best
available science in establishing flows or levels under this section.
In developing methodologies for establishing flows or levels adequate
to support the recovery of salmon and trout populations, the department
shall consult with the department of fish and wildlife and the
science
panel created under RCW 75.46.050. The department shall periodically
consult with the department of fish and wildlife and the science
panel
to ensure an ongoing application of best available science in its
exercise of authority under this section. The review of existing
methodologies or consideration of proposed revisions shall not
be the
basis for delay in proceeding to comply with the priority establishment
of flows or levels under subsection (3) of this section. +}
{+ (3) For the period beginning July 1,
1999, through June 30,
2003, the department of ecology shall place the highest priority
in
exercising the authority under this section upon the adoption of
flows
or levels for the recovery of depressed salmon and trout populations.
To this end and in consultation with the salmon recovery office
and
with Indian tribes, the department shall establish a schedule for
initiating and completing the establishment of flows or levels
for
state waters that support salmon and trout populations listed or
candidates for listing under the federal endangered species act.
The
schedule shall be consistent with the state's salmon recovery strategy
and shall establish a priority for early action on water bodies
in
which listed or candidate salmon or trout populations are dependent
and
in which inadequate flows or levels have been identified as a limiting
factor on recovery. The schedule shall include the review
and revision
of existing flows or levels when determined by the department to
fail
to meet the standards of this section. The schedule shall adopt
as a
goal the establishment or revision of flows or levels by June 30,
2001,
for all waters of the state that support salmon or trout populations
that as of July 1, 1999, are listed or proposed for listing under
the
federal endangered species act, and for which flows or levels in
such
waters have been identified as a limiting factor on recovery. +}
Sec. 4. RCW 90.22.030 and 1988 c
127 s 81 are each amended to read
as follows: {+ Except as provided in RCW
90.03.345, t +}he establishment of
levels and flows pursuant to RCW 90.22.010 shall in no way affect
existing water and storage rights and the use thereof, including
but
not limited to rights relating to the operation of any hydroelectric
or
water storage reservoir or related facility. No right to
divert or
store public waters shall be granted by the department of ecology
which
shall conflict with regulations adopted pursuant to RCW 90.22.010
and
90.22.020 establishing flows or levels. All regulations establishing
flows or levels shall be filed in a "Minimum Water Level and Flow
Register" of the department of ecology.
Sec. 5. RCW 90.03.345 and 1979 ex.s.
c 216 s 7 are each amended to
read as follows:
{+ (1) Except as provided in subsection
(2) of this section, t +}he
establishment of reservations of water for agriculture, hydroelectric
energy, municipal, industrial, and other beneficial uses under
RCW
90.54.050(1) or (({- minimum -})) flows or levels under RCW 90.22.010
or 90.54.040 {+ adopted before January 1, 1999, +} shall constitute
appropriations within the meaning of this chapter with priority
dates
as of the effective dates of their establishment. {+ Flows
or levels
adopted after January 1, 1999, shall have a priority date as of
the
date of the issuance of notice of rule making, or the effective
date of
an emergency rule establishing the flow or level. +} Whenever
an
application for a permit to make beneficial use of public waters
embodied in a reservation, established after September 1, 1979,
is
filed with the department of ecology after the effective date of
such
reservation, the priority date for a permit issued pursuant to
an
approval by the department of ecology of the application shall
be the
effective date of the reservation.
{+ (2) The governor may assign an earlier
priority date of a flow
or level adopted under subsection (1) of this section when necessary
to
avoid the unlawful taking of a listed salmon or trout species under
the
federal endangered species act. The governor's action shall
be
designed solely to avoid such a taking and shall be designed to
minimize the impacts upon the exercise of water rights having an
earlier priority date than that of the flow or level in the absence
of
the governor's action. The governor shall endeavor to provide
prior
notice to water rights holders potentially impacted by action under
this section. The governor shall direct the department to
schedule a
public hearing within the basin for which the action is proposed
and
shall consider public comments received before taking the action.
In
determining whether action may be necessary under this section,
the
governor shall consult with entities charged with monitoring water
flows and levels, water usage, and fish habitat in the area.
An action
by the governor may not extend more than one hundred eighty days
but
may be renewed if necessary to avoid such a taking. When
an action is
taken under this subsection in a basin in which watershed planning
is
being conducted under chapter 90.82 RCW, the governor shall request
the
planning unit to recommend measures to address streamflow requirements
for listed salmon or trout species that will make action under
this
subsection unnecessary. +}
Sec. 6. RCW 90.03.247 and 1996 c
186 s 523 are each amended to
read as follows:
{+ (1) +} Whenever an application for
a permit to make beneficial
use of public waters is approved relating to a stream or other
water
body for which (({- minimum -})) flows or levels have been adopted
and
are in effect at the time of approval, the permit shall be conditioned
to protect the levels or flows. No agency may establish (({-
minimum -
})) flows and levels or similar water flow or level restrictions
for
any stream or lake of the state other than the department of ecology
whose authority to establish is exclusive, as provided in chapter
90.03
RCW and RCW 90.22.010 and 90.54.040. (({- The provisions
of other
statutes, including but not limited to RCW 75.20.100 and chapter
43.21C
RCW, may not be interpreted in a manner that is inconsistent with
this
section. -})) In establishing such (({- minimum -})) flows,
levels, or
similar restrictions {+ under authority provided in chapters 90.03,
90.22, and 90.54 RCW +}, the department shall, during all stages
of
development by the department of ecology of (({- minimum -})) flow
proposals, consult with, and carefully consider the recommendations
of,
the department of fish and wildlife, the department of community,
trade, and economic development, the department of agriculture,
and
representatives of the affected Indian tribes. Nothing herein
shall
preclude the department of fish and wildlife, the department of
community, trade, and economic development, or the department of
agriculture from presenting its views on (({- minimum -})) flow
needs
at any public hearing or to any person or agency, and the department
of
fish and wildlife, the department of community, trade, and economic
development, and the department of agriculture are each empowered
to
participate in proceedings of the federal energy regulatory commission
and other agencies to present its views on (({- minimum -})) flow
needs.
{+ (2) Before July 1, 2001, the department
shall not issue
additional permits for the withdrawal of surface or ground waters
from
water sources where:
(a) No flow or level has been adopted
for the water source, or an
adopted flow or level is determined by the department to require
revision to meet the flow adoption standard under RCW 90.22.010;
(b) The water source is included within
the designated habitat of
one or more fish stocks listed under the federal endangered species
act
or are proposed for listing; and
(c) Adequate streamflows for fish are
a limiting factor on recovery
of such fish stocks. Notwithstanding the limitations of this
subsection (2), the department may issue a temporary permit to
address
a public health or safety emergency, where the permit conditions
are
designed to minimize impacts on adequate streamflows for fish.
+}
Sec. 7. RCW 75.20.050 and 1993 sp.s.
c 2 s 29 are each amended to
read as follows:
It is the policy of this state that a
flow of water (({- sufficient
-})) {+ adequate +} to support game fish and food fish populations
be
maintained at all times in the streams of this state.
The director of ecology shall give the
director {+ of fish and
wildlife +} notice of each application for a permit to divert or
store
water {+ or for approval of a change or transfer under RCW 90.03.380
or
90.44.100. The same notice shall be given to the director
of the
office of salmon recovery when the application relates to a water
source included within the designated critical habitat of a fish
stock
listed or proposed for listing under the federal endangered species
act
+}. The director{+ s +} (({- has -})) {+ have +} thirty days
after
receiving the notice to state his or her objections to the application.
The permit shall not be issued until the thirty-day period has
elapsed.
The director of ecology may refuse to
issue a permit if, in the
opinion of the director, issuing the permit might result in lowering
the flow of water in a stream below the flow necessary to adequately
support food fish and game fish populations in the stream.
{+
Alternatively, the director of ecology may issue the permit with
conditions, including restrictions upon the season or quantity
of use,
to prevent withdrawals under the permit from lowering the flow
below
that flow necessary to adequately support food fish and game fish
populations in the stream. +}
The provisions of this section shall in
no way affect existingwater rights.
{+ NEW SECTION. +} Sec. 8.
A new section is added to chapter
90.03 RCW to read as follows:
A right to the beneficial use of water
may be maintained and
established without a physical diversion of water and that right
may be
held by any person or by a unit of state or local government.
{+ NEW SECTION. +} Sec. 9.
A new section is added to chapter
90.03 RCW to read as follows:
(1) A person transferring a right to the
beneficial use of water
for instream purposes shall file a notice of the transfer with
the
department stating the name and address of the person or governmental
unit to whom the right has been transferred.
(2) Such a transfer for instream purposes
may be permanent or
temporary. A temporary transfer may remain in effect for
any length of
time as determined by the water right holder. The holder
of the water
right temporarily transferred to instream purposes may transfer
all or
part of the water right to the use for which the water right was
initially granted at any time the holder chooses.
Sec. 10. RCW 90.03.380 and 1997
c 442 s 801 are each amended to
read as follows:
(1) The right to the use of water which
has been applied to a
beneficial use in the state shall be and remain appurtenant to
the land
or place upon which the same is used: PROVIDED, HOWEVER,
That the
right may be transferred to another or to others and become appurtenant
to any other land or place of use without loss of priority of right
theretofore established if such change can be made without detriment
or
injury to existing rights. The point of diversion of water
for
beneficial use or the purpose of use may be changed, if such change
can
be made without detriment or injury to existing rights. A
change in
the place of use, point of diversion, and/or purpose of use of
a water
right to enable irrigation of additional acreage or the addition
of new
uses may be permitted if such change results in no increase in
the
annual consumptive quantity of water used under the water right.
For
purposes of this section, "annual consumptive quantity" means the
estimated or actual annual amount of water diverted pursuant to
the
water right, reduced by the estimated annual amount of return flows,
averaged over the most recent five-year period of continuous beneficial
use of the water right. Before any transfer of such right
to use water
or change of the point of diversion of water or change of purpose
of
use can be made, any person having an interest in the transfer
or
change, shall file a written application therefor with the department,
and the application shall not be granted until notice of the
application is published as provided in RCW 90.03.280. If
it shall
appear that such transfer or such change may be made without injury
or
detriment to existing rights, the department shall issue to the
applicant a certificate in duplicate granting the right for such
transfer or for such change of point of diversion or of use.
The
certificate so issued shall be filed and be made a record with
the
department and the duplicate certificate issued to the applicant
may be
filed with the county auditor in like manner and with the same
effect
as provided in the original certificate or permit to divert water.
(2) {+ An instream use right approved
under this section receives
the same priority date as the water right from which it originated.
The department shall identify the stream reach or reaches to which
the
right applies.
(3) +} If an application for change proposes
to transfer water
rights from one irrigation district to another, the department
shall,
before publication of notice, receive concurrence from each of
the
irrigation districts that such transfer or change will not adversely
affect the ability to deliver water to other landowners or impair
the
financial integrity of either of the districts.
(({- (3) -})) {+ (4) +} A change in place
of use by an individual
water user or users of water provided by an irrigation district
need
only receive approval for the change from the board of directors
of the
district if the use of water continues within the irrigation district,
and when water is provided by an irrigation entity that is a member
of
a board of joint control created under chapter 87.80 RCW, approval
need
only be received from the board of joint control if the use of
water
continues within the area of jurisdiction of the joint board and
the
change can be made without detriment or injury to existing rights.
(({- (4) -})) {+ (5) +} This section shall
not apply to trust water
rights acquired by the state through the funding of water conservation
projects under chapter 90.38 RCW or RCW 90.42.010 through 90.42.070.
Sec. 11. RCW 90.42.080 and 1993
c 98 s 4 are each amended to read
as follows:
(1) The state may acquire all or portions
of existing water rights,
by purchase, gift, or other appropriate means other than by
condemnation, from any person or entity or combination of persons
or
entities. Once acquired, such rights are trust water rights.
{+ A
water right acquired by the state that is expressly conditioned
upon
the use being limited to instream purposes shall be administered
as a
trust water right in compliance with that condition. +}
(2) The department may enter into leases,
contracts, or such other
arrangements with other persons or entities as appropriate, to
ensure
that trust water rights acquired in accordance with this chapter
may be
exercised to the fullest possible extent.
(3) Trust water rights may be acquired
by the state on a temporary
or permanent basis.
(4) The provisions of RCW 90.03.380 and
90.03.390 apply to
transfers of water rights under this section.
(5) No funds may be expended for the purchase
of water rights by
the state pursuant to this section unless specifically appropriated
for
this purpose by the legislature.
{+ NEW SECTION. +} Sec. 12.
A new section is added to chapter
90.03 RCW to read as follows:
Using funds specifically appropriated
for the purpose of the
acquisition of temporary or permanent rights to withdraw water,
the
department may contract with any person for the acquisition of
such
rights, if the contract provides that for the term of the acquisition
the right will be maintained for the benefit of the public for
the
maintenance and augmentation of streamflows.
Sec. 13. RCW 90.14.160 and 1981
c 291 s 1 are each amended to read
as follows: Any person entitled to divert
or withdraw waters of the state
through any appropriation authorized by enactments of the legislature
prior to enactment of chapter 117, Laws of 1917, or by custom,
or by
general adjudication, who abandons the same, or who voluntarily
fails,
without sufficient cause, to beneficially use all or any part of
said
right to divert or withdraw for any period of five successive years
after September 1, 1979, shall relinquish such right or portion
thereof, and said right or portion thereof shall revert to the
state,
and the waters affected by said right shall become available for
appropriation in accordance with RCW 90.03.250. {+ After
June 30,
1999, any water rights relinquished under this section as a result
of
failure to use water beneficially shall be dedicated to and managed
in
accordance with the trust water rights program established under
chapter 90.42 RCW if the relinquished water right is needed and
can be
used to protect or restore streamflows. +}
Sec. 14. RCW 90.14.170 and 1967
c 233 s 17 are each amended to
read as follows:
Any person entitled to divert or withdraw
waters of the state by
virtue of his ownership of land abutting a stream, lake, or
watercourse, who abandons the same, or who voluntarily fails, without
sufficient cause, to beneficially use all or any part of said right
to
withdraw or divert said water for any period of five successive
years
after July 1, 1967, shall relinquish such right or portion thereof,
and
such right or portion thereof shall revert to the state, and the
waters
affected by said right shall become available for appropriation
in
accordance with the provisions of RCW 90.03.250. {+ After
June 30,
1999, any water rights relinquished under this section as a result
of
failure to use water beneficially shall be dedicated to and managed
in
accordance with the trust water rights program established under
chapter 90.42 RCW if the relinquished water right is needed and
can be
used to protect or restore streamflows. +}
Sec. 15. RCW 90.14.180 and 1987
c 109 s 101 are each amended to
read as follows:
Any person hereafter entitled to divert
or withdraw waters of the
state through an appropriation authorized under RCW 90.03.330,
90.44.080, or 90.44.090 who abandons the same, or who voluntarily
fails, without sufficient cause, to beneficially use all or any
part of
said right to withdraw for any period of five successive years
shall
relinquish such right or portion thereof, and such right or portion
thereof shall revert to the state, and the waters affected by said
right shall become available for appropriation in accordance with
RCW
90.03.250. {+ After June 30, 1999, any water rights relinquished
under
this section as a result of failure to use water beneficially shall
be
dedicated to and managed in accordance with the trust water rights
program established under chapter 90.42 RCW if the relinquished
water
right is needed and can be used to protect or restore streamflows.
+}
All certificates hereafter issued by the department of ecology
pursuant
to RCW 90.03.330 shall expressly incorporate this section by reference.
{+ NEW SECTION. +} Sec. 16.
A new section is added to chapter
90.03 RCW to read as follows:
(1) Beginning in 2000, by September 30th
of each year, the
department shall submit a report on the implementation of chapter
. . ., Laws of 1999 (this act) in the fiscal year completed the
previous June 30th to the appropriate standing committees of the
house
of representatives and senate. The report shall describe
activities
related to instream flow rules and permit actions in which streamflow
protection was a significant consideration.
(2) In the initial report submitted in
2000, the department shall
include a review of the trust water rights program under chapter
90.42
RCW and identify administrative and statutory barriers to obtaining
greater use of trust water rights to augment streamflows and to
provide
a mechanism for meeting both offstream and instream water demands
identified in local watershed plans or other water resource management
plans. The report shall make recommendations for administrative
and
statutory modifications to encourage greater use of the program,
to
provide more timely review and approval of proposed trust water
rights,
and to provide a greater range of circumstances in which the program
may be employed to meet identified instream and offstream water
needs
consistent with applicable watershed plans.
(3) Beginning in 2005, a report need not
be submitted annually but
the department may report periodically.
{+ NEW SECTION. +} Sec. 17.
RCW 90.22.060 and 1998 c 245 s 172 &
1993 sp.s. c 4 s 13 are each repealed.
--- END ---