CRITERIA FOR ESTABLISHING TRUST AND CONFIDENCE
IN RESEARCH RESULTS
 
Conventional Research Naturalistic Research
Internal Validity - Did variations in the
independent variable(s) produce a change in the dependent variable?
Credibility -Will the methodology and its conduct produce findings that are believable and convincing?
External Validity - Can the results of this investigation be generalized to other settings? Transferability - To what other contextually similar settings can these findings be applied?
Reliability - Are the results consistent, repeatable, and predictable from one study to another? Dependability - Within reasonable limits, are the findings consistent with other similar studies?
Objectivity - Are the events under study public and observable so as to allow agreement among investigators? Confirmability - Are both the process and the product of the data collection and analysis auditable by an outside party?
 

Adapted from Lincoln, Y. S., & Guba, E. G. (1985). Naturalistic inquiry. Beverly Hills: Sage.

3 questions to frameIresearch is/notI quantitativeIqualitativeIabstractingIknowledge claimsI asumptionsI

sources of internal validityI criteria for critiqueI