User Login
Sailor Ethics
Kayla Rakes
Response Paper
Billy Budd, Sailor
Sailors have never been presented as the most ethical occupation or class of men, but when faced with a moral dilemma they are forced to make difficult decisions. Unlike land lubbers they do not bring religion into their paradigms but instead focus on law, the consequences of the action, and the betterment of the whole crew.
In the ethical dilemma of Billy Budd the officers are faced with the decision to either condemn him or let him go. Upon discussing their decision Captain Vere states, “But let not warm hearts betray heads that should be cool.” (pg.97). Implying that this is a case that should be handled lawfully not one debating character or intention.
Because of the law as well as a fear of mutiny the officers are forced to determine what is right and what is wrong. At sea their can be no gray lines ethics are seen in black and white. This furthers power dynamics on the ship as the officers have the ability to punish a sailor for anything that is in the gray area of the ethical scale.
Mutiny has been an ever present problem for officers and they must have assert their control over the ship or there is room for sailors to come together and over throw. Captain Vere verbalizes this fear of mutiny by saying, “They would think that we flinch, that we are afraid of them-afraid of practicing a lawful rigor singularly demanded at this juncture, lest it should provoke new troubles.”( pg. 99)
(I want to talk about some irreligion here, if you have any quote suggestions please let me know.)
