Main Page
From religionandsociety
Contents |
RELIGION AND SOCIETY
Winter 2010
Fall/Winter 2009-2010
8/12 Credit Program, Evening and Weekend Studies
Faculty: Suzanne Simons, simonsc@evergreen.edu, X6710 and Stephen Beck, becks@evergreen.edu, X5488
CRN: 20159/202160
Program wiki page: www2.evergreen.edu/wikis/religionandsociety/
Meets: SEM II E1105, Wednesdays, 5:30-9:30 and every other Saturday, 10-5:30
(Jan. 9, 23, Feb. 6, 20, March 6)
12-credit section also meets: Tuesdays, 5:30-9:30, Sem II E2107.
Special expenses: $45 per student to participate in interfaith conference on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, Seattle Feb. 20.
Link to the Program Covenant.
Link to Fall Quarter Schedule.
Fields of Study: Religious Studies, Media Studies, Philosophy (CR)
Note: This website is for both the 8-credit and the 12-credit options. Those parts of the syllabus that are for the 12-credit option are marked "(CR)".
The second of this two-quarter, writing-intensive program focuses on contemporary U.S. perspectives on religion, including how religion frames political and cultural issues within the U.S., and how religion shapes our comprehension of events around the world. Our guiding questions include what were the political and cultural forces that shaped religion in the U.S. during the course of our country’s history? What are the similarities and differences between a secular nation and a religious one? What is the place of religion in public political discourse, in which not all citizens share religious beliefs? How does mass media influence the ways we think about religion, and the relationship between religion and politics?
Students enrolling in the 12-credit option will study techniques of critical reasoning, with a focus on rhetorical techniques of persuasion, both fallacious and valid, and their presence in media and popular writing about religion.
Students who successfully complete both quarters of the program will understand the development and the major tenets of several major religions, understand the roles of religions within historical and contemporary cultures, and be able to critically evaluate texts on religion as well as claims about the place of religion in public life. Major areas of study will include philosophy, religious studies, history and writing.
Specifically, we will examine:
- The history of religion in the U.S., particularly tensions between “conservative” and “progressive” Christianity as played out in pulpits and politics from the country’s founding to today.
- Mass media coverage and representations of religion in mainstream, alternative, international and specialty publications, and the social, economic and political national and international issues often connected with it.
- Contemporary intersections of religion, politics and culture through case studies in the Middle East, including the Palestinian-Israeli conflict.
Major class activities will include:
- Service learning projects with local faith communities in order to deepen students’ understanding of those communities and how their practices, beliefs and activities intersect with our program studies. Projects may include creating an enduring public record through writing and photography, depending on the needs and interests of faith communities and students.
- Student-organized public forum on religion in wartime. Students in the program will plan, publicize and implement a community event with guest speakers on a theme relating to religion and society for the Evergreen and greater Olympia communities.
Winter Program Objectives
- Demonstrate understanding of the development of several major religions
- Demonstrate understanding of the roles of religions in historical context
- Demonstrate understanding of the roles of religions in contemporary cultures
- Be able to critique mass media coverage of religion
- Demonstrate understanding on the difference among various types of mass media, their uses and audiences
- Demonstrate critical evaluation of texts on religion
- Be able to critically evaluate claims about the place of religion in contemporary issues
- Be able to write college-level papers
- (CR) Be able to identify fallacious reasoning in popular sources on religion
- (CR) Be able to critique persuasive writing on religion with respect both to rhetorical effectiveness and rational strength
Required Readings
A History of God, Karen Armstrong
The Age of Reason, Thomas Paine
The Scarlet Letter, Nathanial Hawthorne
Head and Heart: American Christianities, Garry Wills
Quoting God: How Media Shape Ideas About Religion and Culture, Claire Badaracco (ed.)
The Many Faces of Political Islam: Religion and Politics in the Muslim World, Mohammed Ayoob
(CR) Logic and Contemporary Rhetoric, (11th edition), Nancy Cavender and Howard Kahane
(CR) One of the following texts, associated with “New Atheism”:
- God Is Not Great, Christopher Hitchens
- The God Delusion, Richard Dawkins
- The End of Faith, Sam Harris
Assignments
- Community service project with a local faith community that you are not affiliated with
- Weekly journal of community service work
- Faith community paper and final presentation (3-4 pages)
- History of religion in the U.S. paper (3-4 pages)
- Media analysis of religion reporting paper (3-4 pages)
- Participation in planning and implementation of student-organized religion and society public forum
- Religion memoir (2-3 pages, students new to the program winter quarter only)
- Response papers to required texts (1 page maximum)
- (CR) Critical reasoning problem sets
- February 2: Questions on Sources in Harris, Hitchens or Dawkins
- February 9: Purpose, Audience and Tone in Harris, Hitchens or Dawkins
- February 16: Definition of Terms in Harris, Hitchens or Dawkins
- February 23: Summary of Main Points in Harris, Hitchens or Dawkins
- (CR) Critical review essay (5+ pages)
College-Level Work
You are expected to do college-level work in all program activities. Specifically, this means:
- The ability to read, understand, and then summarize texts
- The ability to learn from texts through discussion with others
- The ability to analyze and pursue writing assignments
- The ability to write coherent, focused, correctly punctuated prose
- The ability to develop and defend a thesis
- The commitment to do all of the above reliably
Program Schedule
Note: Schedule subject to revision. Please check here for the latest version.
Week 1, 1/5-1/9
(CR) Tuesday, 1/5
- Topics: Critical Reasoning Introduction
Review of Central Concepts of Formal Reasoning
Wednesday, 1/6
- Theme: Introduction to Religion and Society
- Activities:
- Introductions and program overview
- Lecture: The Historical Context of the Reformation (Stephen)
- Student survey – do in class
- Introductions and program overview
Saturday,1/9
- Theme: Introduction to Religion and Society
- Readings:
- Quoting God, foreword + pp. 1-36, 43-58, 79-99, 107-128, 193-200
- Quoting God, foreword + pp. 1-36, 43-58, 79-99, 107-128, 193-200
- Activities:
- Faith community service orientation -- see Faith Community Service Learning Project Handout
- Lecture: Religion Coverage in Mass Media (Suzanne)
- Media Groups orientation -- see Media Workshop handout and the News Groups Assignment
- Seminar, assigned readings
- Public forum signup and planning
- Faith community service orientation -- see Faith Community Service Learning Project Handout
- Work Due:
- New students - Religion memoir and map (2-3 pages)
- Response to assigned reading (1 page)
Week 2, 1/12-1/13
(CR) Tuesday, 1/12
- Topic:Reasoning, Persuasion, and Rhetoric
- Readings:
- Kahane, ch. 1-3
- Kahane, ch. 1-3
- Work Due: Problem sets
Wednesday, 1/13
- Theme: Religion and Community
- Readings:
- Head and Heart, pp. 1-117;
- The Scarlet Letter, through chapter X.
- Head and Heart, pp. 1-117;
- Activities:
- Faith community service learning panel: Sister Monika Ellis, St. Placid Priory; Ellen Shortt-Sanchez, director, TESC Center for Community-Based Learning and Action, Rev. Howard Ullery, Lacey Community Church, TBA
- Forum planning update – student committee
- Seminar: Assigned readings
- Faith community service learning panel: Sister Monika Ellis, St. Placid Priory; Ellen Shortt-Sanchez, director, TESC Center for Community-Based Learning and Action, Rev. Howard Ullery, Lacey Community Church, TBA
- Work Due:
- Response to assigned reading
- Community service journal
Week 3, 1/19-1/23
(CR) Tuesday, 1/19
- Topic: Fallacious Reasoning
- Readings:
- Kahane, ch. 4 & 5
- Kahane, ch. 4 & 5
- Work Due: Problem sets
Wednesday,1/20
- Theme: The Enlightenment and Religion
- Readings:
- The Scarlet Letter, to end;
- Head and Heart, pp. 121-171.
- The Scarlet Letter, to end;
- Activities:
- Public forum update – student planning committee
- Community service check-in
- Seminar: Assigned reading
- Public forum update – student planning committee
- Work Due:
- Response to assigned reading
- Community service journal
Saturday,1/23
- Theme: The Enlightenment and Religion
- Readings:
- History of God, ch. 9;
- Age of Reason, pp. 1-84;
- Head and Heart, pp. 173-249 (recommended).
- History of God, ch. 9;
- Activities:
- Lecture: The Enlightenment and Religion (Stephen)
- Media Workshop: Think tanks
- Seminar: Assigned reading
- Work Due:
- Response to assigned reading
- Media journal
Week 4, 1/26-1/27
(CR) Tuesday, 1/26
- Topic: Why Fallacies are Effective
- Readings:
- Cavender and Kahane, ch. 6
- Work Due: Problem sets
Wednesday,1/27
- Theme: Religion in the 19th Century
- Readings:
- Wills, Head and Heart, pp. 253-349
- Wills, Head and Heart, pp. 253-349
- Activities:
- History paper - small group presentations
- Forum update –student planning committee
- Film
- Seminar: Assigned reading
- History paper - small group presentations
- Work Due:
- Response to assigned reading
- Community service journal
- U.S religion history paper (See Guidelines) (3-5 pages)
Week 5, 2/2-2/6
(CR) Tuesday, 2/2
- Readings:
- Harris, The End of Faith, through ch. 3 OR
- Hitchens, God Is Not Great, through c. 9 OR
- Dawkins, The God Delusion, through ch. 5
- Harris, The End of Faith, through ch. 3 OR
- Topic: The New Atheism: Workshop on Dawkins, Harris and Hitchens
- Video: Debate between Sam Harris and Reza Aslan
- Work Due: Questions on Sources in Harris, Hitchens or Dawkins
Wednesday, 2/3
- Theme: Culture Wars
- Readings:
- Head and Heart, pp. 353-396
- Activities:
- Lecture: Religion and Politics (Stephen)
- Forum Update -- student planning committee
- Faith community service check-in
- Seminar: Assigned reading
- Lecture: Religion and Politics (Stephen)
- Work Due:
- Response to assigned reading
- Faith community service journal -- see Worship Service Observation Guidelines
Saturday,2/6
- Theme: Culture Wars
- Readings:
- Head and Heart, pp. 397-446
- History of God, ch. 10
- Head and Heart, pp. 397-446
- Activities:
- Lecture: Religion and the Pacific Northwest (Suzanne)
- Seminar: Assigned reading
- Media group presentations
- Program reflection/quiz
- Mid-quarter conferences
- Lecture: Religion and the Pacific Northwest (Suzanne)
- Work Due:
- Response to assigned reading
- Media journal
- Response to assigned reading
Week 6, 2/9-2/10
(CR) Tuesday, 2/9
- Readings:
- Cavender and Kahane, ch. 7
- Cavender and Kahane, ch. 7
- Topic: Emotive and Cognitive Language
- Work Due: Purpose, Audience and Tone in Dawkins, Harris and Hitchens
Wednesday, 2/10
- Theme: Framing Conflicts
- Readings:
- Head and Heart, pp. 451-494 (495-552 recommended)
- Quoting God, pp. 211-231.
- Head and Heart, pp. 451-494 (495-552 recommended)
- Activities:
- Lecture: Competing Media Frames: Israeli-Palestinian Conflict as Colonial Project or Religious Destiny? (Suzanne)
- Forum update -- student planning committee
- Faith community service check-in
- Seminar: Assigned reading
- Lecture: Competing Media Frames: Israeli-Palestinian Conflict as Colonial Project or Religious Destiny? (Suzanne)
- Work Due:
- Response to assigned reading
- community service journal
- Response to assigned reading
Week 7, 2/16-2/20
(CR) Tuesday, 2/16
- Readings:
- Cavender and Kahane, ch. 11
- Cavender and Kahane, ch. 11
- Topic: Critical reasoning and analysis of news media
- Work Due: Definition of Terms in Harris, Hitchens or Dawkins
Wednesday,2/17
- Theme: Religion in the Contemporary World
- Readings:
- Political Islam, in entirety
- Activities:
- Lecture: Political Islams' Many Voices (Suzanne)
- Film -- Peace, Propaganda and the Promised Land
- Forum update -- student planning committee
- Seminar: Assigned readings
- Lecture: Political Islams' Many Voices (Suzanne)
- Work Due:
- Response to assigned reading
- community service journal
- Response to assigned reading
Saturday,2/20
- Theme: Religion in the Contemporary World
- Activities:
- Sabeel Conference, Seattle. See Friends of Sabeel -- North America and Sabeel Seattle Conference
- All-day field trip. $45 to be paid to student accounts; van drivers needed.
- Work Due:
- Conference reflection (written on site)
- Conference reflection (written on site)
Week 8, 2/23-2/24
(CR) Tuesday, 2/23
- Readings: Remainder of
- Harris, The End of Faith OR
- Hitchens, God Is Not Great OR
- Dawkins, The God Delusion
- Harris, The End of Faith OR
- Topic: Discussion of "New Atheism"
- Work Due: Summary of main points
Wednesday, 2/24
- Theme: Religion in the Media
- Readings:
- Quoting God, pp. 59-66, 233-245, 259-263
- Quoting God, pp. 59-66, 233-245, 259-263
- Activities:
- Media analysis paper -- small group presentations
- Forum update -- student planning committee
- Program quiz and reflection
- Seminar: Assigned reading
- Media analysis paper -- small group presentations
- Work Due:
- Media analysis paper (3-5 pages)
- Community service journal
- Response to assigned readings
Week 9, 3/2-3/6
(CR) Tuesday, 3/2
- Readings:
- Excerpts from two sources critical of Harris, Hitchens or Dawkins, plus | Karen Armstrong, "Think Again: God", along with | Sam Harris' reply, "The God Fraud"
- Excerpts from two sources critical of Harris, Hitchens or Dawkins, plus | Karen Armstrong, "Think Again: God", along with | Sam Harris' reply, "The God Fraud"
- Activities:
- Video, debate between Hitchens and Boteach
- Concurrent seminars on each text and critics
- Video, debate between Hitchens and Boteach
- Work Due:
- Summary of main points of critical sources
Wednesday, 3/3
- Theme: Religion in War Time
- Activities:
- Religion and Society Community Forum -- Evergreen Longhouse
- Religion and Society Community Forum -- Evergreen Longhouse
- Work:
- Students responsible for Longhouse setup, hosting and welcoming, distributing programs, and take-down
- Community service journal
Saturday, 3/6
- Activities:
- Self-evaluation workshop
- Faith community poster presentations and family potluck
- Self-evaluation workshop
- Work Due:
- Poster presentation with your field supervisor on your faith community work
- Faith community paper (3-5 pages)
- Poster presentation with your field supervisor on your faith community work
Week 10, 3/9-10
(CR) Tuesday, 3/9
- Activities:
- Presentations of critical review essays, in groups
- Quiz
- Presentations of critical review essays, in groups
- Work Due:
Wednesday, 3/10
- Readings:
- History of God, ch. 11
- Activities:
- Program de-brief
- Seminar: Assigned readings
- Program de-brief
- Work Due:
- Response to assigned reading
- Program portfolio with self-evaluation
Evaluation Week, 3/15-19
Activities
- Self-evaluation critique groups
- Evaluation conferences
Full credit for the program requires attendance at your evaluation conference. Your seminar faculty’s evaluation of you will be based on your depth of understanding and progress as evident in papers, class portfolio and seminar participation.
Faculty evaluation (at time of final conference. May be given to faculty, or to EWS program secretary Sharon Wendt, Sem II B 2124)