As per the assignment I investigated these four topics: Challenger, Paull [sic] Shin, WWII Straglers, and the letest episode of “How I met Your Mother (HIMYM)” (Season 9, Episode 14) and related them back to the program.
At a club meeting early in the day I remembered that I had to complete this assignment. In a boring fashion I started at the beigning of the list and worked my way down. After researching “Challenger” the connection I came up with was that Ellison Shoji Onizuka was aboard that space shuttle and it’s explosion had a tone of media coverage. Onizuka was the first Asian/American in space, reaching the destination in 1985 and was one of the seven people that about a year later on the Challenger mission.
After reading the above topic and feeling a little down I moved on to read about Paull Shin. Born in South Korea in 1935 and adopted to Ray Paull, a U.S. Army officer who was in South Korea for the war, Paull Shin became the first Korean/American elected to the Washington State Legislation.
I found the World War II Stragglers to be quite interesting in two respects. According to Wikipedia’s Japanese Holdout, Japanese soldiers located throughout the Pacific kept on fighting the War till the 1980s. Wikipedia suggests the reasoning behind these stragglers was either due to the loss of communication during the end of the war so they did not get the message or because of the Japanese “strong dogmatic or militaristic principles”, which I’m assuming the writer on the post was referring to bushido , as this article points out is a code that “demands bravery and unflinching self-sacrifice. Honor comes from death, disgrace from surrender.” All of that I found interesting because it was not something I had heard of before and that time wise WWII was not over till the 1980s. Which got me thinking of our programs theme with time and how despite the reasoning behind the Japanese soldiers continuing to fight for them a war that for others was in the past and over was still a present aspect in their lives. And I was feeling pretty good about how nice these connections were seeming to come along, till I moved on to the last topic.
Before searching the news for Episode 14 of “How I Met Your Mother” I decided to watch it. Now I use to watch this show all the time and like it. I had a bit of info on the episode from a friend who pointed out from her musing online, the main racist themes of yellowface, and usual mockery of culture but also that this show doesn’t have a ton of non-white actors in it which adds to the impact this had. So I was on the watch for this as I started the episode, but there was no missing any of it. My first notes on the episode start as Marshall goes to learn a mighty slap at a Kung Fu school. In this scene when he asks the instructor if he can learn a slap and the instructor says no because he teaches Kung Fu that is a sacred art (which they make fun of the whole episode) and not slapping, Marshall acts out his words like the instructor doesn’t know what he is talking about. To make this scene even better in the background there are Katanas along the walls. After learning that there is a special slap that he can learn from masters Marshall embarks on his journey. We have Robin and Lilli, dressed in Chinese attire and both are made fun of their age by looking younger than they are. And while their make-up is done in a “China Doll” fashion they weren’t as bad a Ted. With Ted waring a wig of long braided hair to simulate Chinese historical hair customs, he is mistaken as a women and then turns to show the audience his face with the long eyebrows and long goatee that wise masters have in Kung Fu movies.
After being enraged over what I saw I looked up news articles for the episode and what I found frustrated me even more. All the articles that popped up on the first page were on the creators apology for their unintentional racism with the exception of Kai Ma’s Article Dear How I Met Your Mother: ‘Asian’ Is Not a Costume. All the articles had the statement from the creators that said while they were trying to have a laugh at Kung Fu movies, which they hold dear (Obviously because Katana’s are a part of Kung Fu), they did not mean to offend anyone. And while some also included some of the tweets that went out like “#YellowFace” and “#HowIMetYourRacisim” they did not go into the real issues like Ma’s article. The big reason the focus on the apology and the apology itself frustrates me is this intention vs. impact concept (if you want to know more or don’t know what I’m talking about check this out). Yes the creators just wanted to make fun of Kung Fu movies and didn’t want to hurt or upset anyone but they did and instead of trying to understand how they did offend people their apology only defends what they did.