So far I’ve written about Zen Guitar and several about its application to my practice/playing, Asian/American guitar & bass players, connections between guitars/music and motorcycles… so are there any other crosscurrents between Asia and the US?
Of course! Starting with the connections between East & West manufactures. The reasoning for US builders branching out to include Asian versions of their instruments varies. Most simply want to add a lower cost version of their instruments that appeal to begginers and the budget minded. Larger companies such as Fender add that having guitars built in several Asian locations enables them to meet production demands around the world.
Many Asian versions of American models are very high quality. Most are reasonably priced– usually around half what their original American made versions sell for. The lower prices are usually atonable through use of lower quality woods, parts, and the lower cost of manufacturing usually through subcontractors. For instance, World Musical Instrument Co, in South Korea is one of the worlds largest manufacture of guitars. They are a subcontractor for all the big names such as Fender, PRS, Gibson, and many other companies. Cort and Samick are also Asian makers of the three who claim to be the worlds largest. Either way, these factories produce far more instruments than are produced in the US. And this is good news for beginners, the budget minded, or anyone who wants a nice guitar at a lower price than an American made guitar.
Among the more popular Asian/American imports is G&L. It’s the company founded by Leo Fender (founder of Fender guitars), and the last place Leo worked before his death in March 1991. G&L recently added a line of imported guitars under the “Tribute” banner. These are guitars built in Indonesia to G&L’s specs and fitted with American made G&L electronics– which is one of the things that sets the Tribute series apart from its competitors. Typically the Asian import models from companies such as Gibson, Fender, and PRS, feature electronics that are “designed by” the parent company. This means the quality of the guitars electronics are a far cry from that of the parent companies.
Surfing YouTube’s collection of head-to-head videos shows that the Asian models are very close to the quality of the US versions. Here are a few such videos– some results are very surprising!
USA vs Inport G&L comparison (great history & info, less-great musicianship in this video)
Click here to view the embedded video.
G&L Tribute L-2000 Bass review
Click here to view the embedded video.
Another US manufacturer, Music Man (a division of Ernie Ball) also have an Asian import series which are marketed under the name “Sterling by Music Man.” These basses have received quite a bit of praise as well:
Click here to view the embedded video.
The Gibson guitar company has been building guitars and basses in the US for many, many years and are considered among the leaders in the production of musical instruments. Their Asian import models are marketed under the “Ephiphone” moniker. There have been a lot of issues with Gibson in the last 10-years or so that call into question the quality of their US made instruments. This video compares the US made Les Paul model with an Asian made Les Paul model. Again, the results will surprise you (musicianship is much better with these guitarists…):
Click here to view the embedded video.
US Gibson vs. Asian Ephiphone “Slash model” comparison
Click here to view the embedded video.
All of this is the up-side of the Asian import guitar market. Stay tuned for the dark-side… coming next~