Kato Ch4 & Enter the Dragon

Autonomy
- (of a country or region) The right or condition of self-government, especially in a particular sphere.
- Freedom from external control or influence.
- (in Kantian moral philosophy) the capacity of an agent to act in accordance with objective morality rather than under the influence of desires

Aesthetic
- Concerned with beauty or the appreciation of beauty
- A set of principles underlying and guiding the work of a particular artist or artistic movement

The above terms are familiar to most of us, but in reading Kato I’ve found it useful to revisit the definitions. Doing so gave me a renewed perspective. For instance, Autonomy is the lens through which Enter the Dragon is critically reexamined (p114). Think of the Greek origins of Autonomy, then consider the background of Enter the Dragon:

Autos (self)
Nomos (law)

 Kayto describes how the Hong Kong crew was treated subserviently during the making of Enter the Dragon, and the allegory for colonial antagonism antagonism toward the transnational power that was the Hollywood production crew. “Self-law” would have been the last term used by the Hong Kong crew to describe their treatment.

One form of subversion used by the Hong Kong crew was the fact most could understand English, but kept this fact from the Hollywood producers– who couldn’t speak any Chinese– and relied on an interpreter who refused to tip the hand of the Hong Kong workers.

It has been many years since I’ve seen the film “Enter the Dragon.” In fact I just learned that it was not even included in my 5-Disc Masters Collectors Edition (?!). Now, after watching Enter the Dragon, There were many things that caught my attention in the context of Kato’s writing, but none as much as the aesthetics of the film.

The first thing is how much it feels like a James Bond film. Everything from the music, to the storyline and even the props– all feel like they just finished filming 007, and Enter the Dragon was next on the set.

Take the plot line for example; if this was a typical kung fu movie Bruce Lee would be setting off to Han’s island to avenge the death of his sister– a revenge film. In this Western adaptation however, a British official sends Lee to Han’s island because he knows that Han is up to no good– he just can’t prove it– that’s Lee’s job. Lee doesn’t learn of his sister’s death until after he’s accepted the mission for Britain. So is he on an undercover secret mission for Britain, or is he seeking revenge for the death of his sister? Granted, this confusion is somewhat reconciled when Lee confronts Han just before the climatic battle and he says, “You have offended my family and you have offended the Shaolin Temple.” Kato would probably say this is an example of the transnational colonization of the kung fu culture. The only thing that keeps the movie together is Lee’s performance. Just like he instructs his student at the beginning of the film, Lee puts all of his “emotional content” into the film. I can hear Kato saying that’s Bruce Lee liberating the genre from the colonization of Western globalization.

bruce-lee

The aesthetics of the film are therefore both obvious, and hidden. The obvious of course is in the kung fu battles, the outdoor setting and actors. The less obvious is Bruce Lee’s performance adhering to the second definition of aesthetics; “A set of principles underlying and guiding the work of a particular artist or artistic movement.”
In the end, it was an entertaining film and the book provided more information about it than I could fully appreciate in one reading. A situation that could benefit from Lee’s advice to his student; “Do not concentrate on the finger or you will miss all of the heavenly glory!

 

Impressions on Enter the Dragon and Ch. 4

Main points to be looking out for in this film is the personification of Han as the Dr. Fu Manchu of this piece. Will he be as cunning and dangerous as they described for Fu Manchu. Bruce Lee’s role will be reminiscent of the “good Asian” or Charlie Chan. Another connection is how Bruce Lee is working under cover to infiltrate Han’s island, which brings in the theme of infiltration and espionage, although I don’t recall “Lee” being 100% with the idea. A particular thing to look out for is the extras and actors reactions during Bruce Lee’s and Ohara’s fight. In reality, there was a falling with Bob Wall, the actor of Ohara, and Bruce Lee during the shooting of the scene of Lee breaking the glass bottles Ohara tries to use against “Lee”. It turns out the bottles were in fact real and cost bodily injury to Lee that suspended him from acting for a week. When they shot that scene again, “Lee” continued on to wail on Ohara, which got the Chinese extras all riled up because they were being mistreated and viewed stereotypically. Even the extras that were part of the bad guys got excited over the fight between “Lee” and Ohara, or Lee and Hall. Finally the quest Lee is taking not only to take down Han, but for Lee to avenge the Shaolin school since Han was once a student of the school The senior monk requests that “Lee” remove Han from power so that he does not dishonor the school any further. This is an example of the “good Asian” again, but this time for a culture that he is affiliated with.

MV5BMTI0Mjg5MjgwNV5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTYwNjE1NjU5._V1_SY317_CR8,0,214,317_For the movie Enter the Dragon, it was almost everything I expected from the reading of Kato. The action was good for a movie of its time, and I was surprised to see Bolo Yeung play as “Bolo” in the movie. I only remember him from the movie Bloodsport where he was the main antagonist against Jean Claude Van Damme. I forgot to put this down earlier, but there was kind of a spy element that was somewhat reminiscent to 007 movies. While “Lee” didn’t have any guns or superficial gadgets, he snuck around with a quality of stealth and used cunning skills to subdue guards and create distractions. Regarding the fight with Ohara, I watched the reaction of the crowds and saw some people jump ecstatically rather than getting up and clapping. They were clearly entertained seeing Wall get the crud beat out of him despite the fact they were not supposed to show much emotion or cheer. For Han, I saw the qualities of a Dr. Fu Manchu stereotype in him. Han was not very masculine and had a sinister appearance to him, sporting the dark gloves and a stand-out robe or uniform that defines him as the head of the school. Han was also ruthless, executing his own guards for their incompetence and murdering Williams for not cooperating with him. He also uses manipulation to try to have Roper work with him in his opium ring, but due to Roper’s rejection, Han has Roper attempt to fight Lee to the death for both of their actions regarding his underground operations. For Lee’s character “Lee”, it did not really portray the Charlie Chan stereotype as much. Sure he was respectful and helped those that were being bullied, like the Chinese on the boat bullied by Parsons, but he also exhibits a punisher-esque attitude by finishing off some of the opponents he ended up fighting against, such as Ohara or the unfortunate guard who tried to take him on but ended getting his neck broken. There was also the moment where a girl was begging for Lee’s help to release her from a testing chamber, but he ignored her plea and continued with his mission. This can be seen from different perspectives though: Either he didn’t think it would be safe at the moment to release her in Han’s fortress, or that he couldn’t concern himself with her because she’s probably going to ruin his sneak attempt. Overall, the film was entertaining, albeit a bit disturbing at some parts, especially with the scene of William’s corpse hanging over a pool. I know some people don’t like fighting, but it is part of the Asian American pop culture that bolstered the confidence of Asian males.

Kato Bruce Lee-Enter the Dragon

Enter the dragon and Kato reading on page 140-141 where it says, “For such a device could fundamentally debase the narrative matrix of the Yi Ho Tuan movement, or what I have also referred to earlier as the kung fu dialectic.” I believe that Bruce Lee really demonstrated this matrix movements besides the slow motion, but doing the combat  so familiarly to the narrative matrix. Bruce Lee reminded me of Neo in the matrix during some of his fights because he was so fluent and precise. The thing that I really appreciated in the book that the remastered version of Enter the Dragon showed was the situation between Han and Lee. In the earlier version some parts were left out and in this one they weren’t. The other thing that was interesting in the book where it talks about the images of an enemy. “Yes. The enemy has only images and illusions, behind which he hides his true motives. Destroy the image and you will break the enemy.” That fight scene with the mirrors and how he broke them, so Han was using the environment to his advantage and then broken glass everywhere and the enemy has nowhere to hide.

On page 156, where one of the contributions in Enter the Dragon was to confront the Japanese self-”Orientalization” of the ninja with the power of realism and historicism. I thought that a ninja was a myth, but reading in the book and seeing in the movie and how it was the art of ninjutsu where people would entertain. Art of the ninja was great to see that from a true inspiring ninja because I was convinced because I couldn’t hear anything from Bruce when he was sneaking around. Lee was I think was the first real-life artist to perform ninja in the films’s history.

This chapter and movie together were awesome to hear about more popular culture involving kung fu and from a character that has shocked the world and put the art of kung fu in a sense into production because Bruce Lee was a barrier breaker, fundamental scholar and was a martial art guru. He was a master at his craft and we know that his legacy is not forgotten.

Enter the Dragon/Games/Royale

On another note, I found it interesting to watch one of the characters ask Lee “What style?” and Lee refuses to show him. That reminded me of Black Kung Fu ExperienceWilliams, the only black character in the movie reminded me of the Black Kung Fu Experience because, not just because of his skin color, but also because it was the opposite of what all the characters in Black Kung Fu Experience said. Most of them did it for the art of it, where as Williams had claimed he’s in it for the win. I thought that was interesting to put that specific answer in the movie.

Also, I noticed that the island, or castle, was like an arena. It sort of reminded me of the Hunger Games in a way that they were all brought there to fight. It also reminded me of Battle Royale because of how they were all “students” still learning the way. Though they were not all there to fight each other one on one, they were there under an experiment to see if any of them would join Han.

My name is Lisa

and I didn’t bomb Pearl Harbor.

As a matter of fact, I wasn’t even alive during WWII and you know what? Neither were my parents. But you see, even though this happened 72 years ago, you all keep blaming me in particular for it and I just don’t understand how you can make that sort of accusation. Scientifically, it makes no sense at all.

I hate the 2001 film Pearl Harbor that starred Ben Affleck and Josh Hartnett. Us Japs killed off that babyface Josh and so many people went wild about this FAKE death. I remember when that movie came out, I was just starting my adventures in A.O.L. chatrooms. When I found out that there was a chatroom for an interest in Japan, my eleven year old self enthusiastically entered one of these chat rooms and when I revealed my ethnic background I was bombarded with messages like :

“YOU KILLED JOSH HARTNETT”

“GO BACK TO YOUR COUNTRY WE HATE YOU HERE”

“JAP, JAP, JAP, KICK THE JAP OUT OF THE ROOM”

Eleven years old. How can you accuse an eleven year old to have taken part in WWII?

In some ways, I relate to Sameer. I could never tell my family the sort of harassment I was facing when I was young. I only wanted to give them good news about my life. How can I tell my mom that her only daughter was being picked on because I am Japanese. Whether it was in school or on the world wide web, I just had to swallow that pain and hope for the best.

There are so many other harmful stereotypes that different people of different backgrounds have and it needs to stop. Please, stop. I am an American. Just like you.

Enter the Dragon, Power, and Subversion

In this chapter, I found how ironic it is for Hollywood wanting to portray this Asian vibe, but strip away a lot of meaning behind certain Asian traditions or ways. On page 119, “Lee attempted to work with him on revisions to bring a more realistic portrayal of the character of Chinese and kung fu philosophy to the script.” Lee tries to push for truth about kung fu and the Chinese way and purpose of things; unfortunately, he had no luck, “The American producers, however, maintained a double face: they consented to Lee’s demand, but secretly arranged a new accommodation for the scriptwriter for a designated period of vacation behind Lee’s back (119).” Overall, Lee was deceived and lied to.

This reminded me of Takaki’s Strangers From a Different Shore and how many Asian immigrants were tricked or fooled into thinking that they would have a great life in the U.S. I see a similarity to this happening to Lee and how many Asians feel for the deceit of America. Also, further into the reading,

After watching Enter the Dragon, the book begins to make more sense about its allegories. The book goes on to explain about the scene and Oharra on page 132, “”‘Lee’s’ face beams forth ever-changing impressions from the wrath of righteous deity, to the indignation of a woman, to the ululation of a child victimized by war.” I take this as a way of empires/countries/colonies suffering the consequences of “war for peace.” It’s ironic. Many expansions are due to this greed of power, or the true belief that one’s ruling is the best way, but the first thing that most people see is war or violence being portrayed.

Overall, I enjoyed the movie  because there was a lot of action, but I also see how it fits in perfectly with the allegories presented. As for my comparison to Takaki, I think that Lee coming up and beating Han would be the rising of the Asian cultures against invaders. Han was Asian himself and the book talks about how many Asian countries had to suffer the consequences of violence and war against other Asian invaders, so I believe that was a good representation of the protagonist and antagonist roles cast in the movie.

 

Enter the Dragon

Jim Kelly basking in the moonlight

The tensions between “Lee” and “Ohara” represent a direct connection between the Hong Kong factory workers and the management, as well as the Chinese crew members and the Hollywood management. The first time I watched this movie, I was puzzled by the reaction of  the henchmen and martial artists in the background when “Lee” handed “Ohara” his own ass on a silver platter. I was unaware of the tensions that made rise into the film but after reading the Kato chapter it made more sense. The henchmen, who were supposed to be backing the evil “Han”, became ecstatic during “Lee’s” victory despite the fact that their boss was the opposing force. “Ohara” had not only done some dirty things in the plot, but the actor Robert Wall also did something questionable on set during the filming of that fight scene.

At the end of the fight, “Ohara” comes at “Lee” with one last-ditch effort, a glass bottle. In the fight, “Lee” hits the bottle out of his hands and finishes him. When they were filming it, however, something went awry. After a few takes, Wall held the bottle too long so when Lee tried to knock it out of his hands, the bottle broke on his hand and wounded him. Bruce Lee had felt like this was intentional and got upset about the whole ordeal, not to mention that Bruce had expressed that he did not get along with Bob. This could be seen as a bit of a turning point for Lee and the rest of the Chinese crew/cast. Throughout the filming, the Chinese workers had been treated terribly. There were many instances during the filming of the movie where the Americans would assume that the Chinese workers couldn’t understand their English, and they would in turn say demeaning things to them. With tensions between the workers and between Lee and Wall rising, the final shot of the fight scene was packed with raw emotion and expression. And instead of showing their loyalty to Han, the henchmen all revealed their true feelings, as well as Lee.

Outside!

 

post in progress

starships

 From Kung Fu to Hip Hop pg. 113 – 169
& Enter the Dragon

I noticed several times while watching the movie that during some of the fight scenes, the “bad guys” in the background were grinning while Bruce Lee kicked ass. This seemed kind of unusual at first, until some discussion with classmates after the film and a bit of searching on google. As it turns out racism was rampant on the set, and it even went as far as many of the actors being treated horribly by their fellow actors. Bruce Lee, however, had no patience for racism whatsoever. In several of the fight scenes he was actually beating the person up, which is why the NPC-like men off to the side looked overjoyed at the time. What the film fails to convey is the very real struggle that many of the actors faced on set, and how Bruce Lee, despite potentially endangering his career, stood up for them.

There were a number of ways in which the film deviated from the standard, which also included the suicide of Su-Lin. While having a very minor part in the film, eventually Su-Lin gets to a point where she can no longer outrun the people who are after her; she’s cornered, and she runs out of options. Of course, this doesn’t mean that she’s doomed necessarily. If she had allowed herself to be taken, there might have been a slim chance that she would survive the ordeal, though surely not without being abused and raped. Instead of allowing the men after her to even lay a hand on her, she chooses to take her own life. In this way she was defiant until the very end, which isn’t something that you get to see very often in films– especially not older ones. For her role in the film she was only paid $100.

tonight we’re on fire

My Name is Kahn

“…And I am not a terrorist.”

It’s amazing in the way that hate can shape the world and the way we perceive it, or the way that we think of others. Something as simple as a name, or a different book of rules, or the color of your skin is enough to have entire countries hating you, not even a specific “you”, but the very idea of something’s existence.

The film was a labor of love, as was the story it was based upon.  It told of triumph in dark times, of love and devotion and loss. It wove a wonderful web that was fantastic to follow, to see all the pieces it connected to at the end of the film. It was honestly a joy to watch, and I was genuinely looking forward to continuing it after we left for lunch on Tuesday. There were a few mentions of some cheesiness, but I didn’t find it cheesy in the slightest.

However, for all the overcoming the movie was about, I also felt that it was a great deal about hatred.

The first example was small; an unfortunate cultural circumstance that, though disheartening, was understandable to a certain extent. Zamir’s unwillingness to approve of the wedding between Khan and Mandira, because Mandira was Hindu and they were Muslim, the basis of their hatred a long war that neither of them were directly connected with. But Khan’s mother taught him equality regardless of these things, and so Khan was unbothered.

The next case was an angry little boy, who had just lost his father to war. He lashed out against his best friend, because he viewed his friend as a source, a reason for his father dying, and this tiny little hate turned into something bigger and fiercer, until the boy was essentially responsible for getting his best friend killed.

There were also hate crimes, things committed against people just because they looked like they could be Muslim; murders and cruel acts of violence.

And then there was the murder attempt made on Khan’s life. All of these acts were driven by hatred, and though the movie was inspiring I felt this was also a connecting theme. For all the good that occurred it was fueled by tragedy, and while I’m glad it had a  good ending where Mandira and Khan could be happy together again, it’s very sad how long and what it took them to get there again after Sam’s loss.

King of Kowloon

So far, when we have discussed the concept of resistance, one of the ways in which a lot of Asian Americans have resisted assimilation in a subtle way is through food, however I think it’s also interesting that to some extent, another form of resistance is through graffiti.

On page 181, Kato talks about the New York subway system and the graffiti marks on the trains  ”…as a means of communication and aesthetic forum that can be called their own.” (181) I feel as though this statement represents breaking the chain from the corporations that run this country and rising above it and claiming something that is the corporations as theirs. Or in other circumstances, giving a police commissioner a mocking name and tagging that name around public spaces as a means to break from the oppression, racism and power of the police force. (179)

This sort of oppression though is happening all around the world and writing on public walls is a great way to resist, or to voice your anger of what is happening to your community yet unfortunately, it seems as though graffiti is something that the youth is doing and this can be seen as a way of comparing how the sansei within the Japanese American community were angrier on the outside than some of the issei or the nisei. However, I think for someone as old as Tsang Tsou Choi to be engaged in the resistance of the colonization of Hong Kong is incredibly admirable because not only did he try to represent himself in the commotion but he represented a large community of Hong Kong who were also against the colonization.

When you write something down, you have to read it out loud and the way Kato segues into the resistant sounds of Grandmaster Flash and others was really great.